New City Players’ strong ensemble brings Ibsen’s uncomfortable questions into an intimate space—and into America’s anniversary year.
A community is easy to celebrate until someone tells it something it cannot afford to hear.
That dilemma sits at the center of An Enemy of the People, presented by New City Players at Island City Stage in Wilton Manors. Directed by Ali Tallman, the production uses Amy Herzog’s adaptation of Henrik Ibsen’s play: a doctor identifies a threat to public health, and the prospect of addressing it threatens the town’s economic survival. Suddenly, being right becomes a complicated social liability.
Dr. Thomas Stockmann discovers that the water supplying the town’s celebrated baths is contaminated. The institution promising health to its visitors is putting them at risk. He expects his discovery to be welcomed as a public service. Instead, the cost of repairs and the threat to the town’s prosperity transform a medical finding into a political problem.
His brother, Peter, is the mayor. The local newspaper has its own interests to consider. As the financial consequences become clear, support for the doctor gives way to resistance. Stockmann’s attempt to bring his case before the public becomes a test of whether a community will listen to evidence that threatens its account of itself.
The progression is painfully recognizable: first question the warning, then question the person delivering it. Who benefits from disclosure? Who pays for action? And when does protecting a town’s reputation become a way of abandoning the people who live there?
Written in 1882, the play has outlived generations of politicians without exhausting those questions. Flint, Michigan, supplies an especially sobering contemporary point of comparison. After the city changed its water source in April 2014, inadequate treatment exposed residents to lead. A subsequent EPA Office of Inspector General investigation identified failures of implementation and oversight at local, state and federal levels.
Flint’s history is distinct from Ibsen’s fictional town. The resonance lies in the distance between a public institution’s duty to protect people and its willingness or ability to respond when something has gone wrong. Evidence alone does not repair a pipe or compel an official to act. Someone must accept responsibility, commit resources and acknowledge that the reassuring version of events is no longer defensible.
That is why a play from the nineteenth century can still feel so close to home. We have more sophisticated ways to test water, distribute information and measure risk. We remain vulnerable to the temptation to postpone an expensive truth. The question of who gets believed—and how long others must live with the consequences before they are—is hardly confined to Ibsen’s century.
The production belongs to the company’s America at 250 season, organized around a question that gives this anniversary something more demanding to do than congratulate itself: What holds us together when everything pushes us apart? Ibsen offers uncomfortable material for that inquiry. Agreement can look remarkably like principle until maintaining it requires a sacrifice.
Nestled in the heart of Wilton Manors, Island City Stage is an ideal, intimate venue for this encounter. There is something particularly effective about considering the pressures within a small community while seated in a theater that feels part of one. The scale brings the evening close. These questions belong within conversational distance.
The production’s strongest asset is its ensemble. Each performer carries a share of the evening’s weight, and the cast works together with a cohesion that makes the collective achievement worth recognizing. A play about the bonds and fractures of a community benefits from precisely that sense of shared purpose.
Ben Sandomir plays Dr. Thomas Stockmann, with Marla Lopez as his daughter, Petra, and Ryan Didato as his brother, Peter. Peter Alexander Pera appears as Hovstad, Chad Raven as Billing, David H. Hepburn as Aslaksen, Timothy Mark Davis as Captain Horster and Michael Gioia as Morten Kiil. Together, they give the production the strength of a genuinely collaborative undertaking.
The distinction matters. Audiences often remember theater through individual performances, but an ensemble asks us to appreciate the relationships among them. Here, the pleasure is in watching a company work well together on a story about people struggling to do the same.
There is also a reason to encounter this play locally. National arguments arrive on our phones already sorted into positions, personalities and reasons to be furious. Theater asks for a different kind of attention. We sit through an exchange rather than scroll past it. We hear an argument develop. We remain in the room.
Local theater companies make that experience available within the ordinary geography of our lives. They provide work for artists, give audiences somewhere to gather and allow a city to develop a cultural identity through the stories it chooses to stage. Their continued presence deserves more than occasional appreciation.
For New City Players, that need is immediate. The company’s Make Room campaign seeks to raise $25,000 by December 31. According to the company, the loss of a government capacity-building grant left a $37,500 gap in funding anticipated for this season. Reaching the campaign goal would cover two-thirds of that shortfall. Ticket sales and season passes, the company says, cover approximately 35 percent of its production costs.
Those figures give practical weight to the evening’s larger question. A community’s cultural life depends on decisions about what it will sustain, who will contribute and what would be lost if no one did.
At America’s 250th anniversary, An Enemy of the People offers an occasion to consider how difficult belonging can become when convictions collide. New City Players gives that consideration a fitting home: a small theater, a strong ensemble and a room full of neighbors.
An Enemy of the People continues through November 29 at Island City Stage, 2304 N. Dixie Highway, Wilton Manors. Production information and tickets. Support the Make Room campaign.
